“Game A is the finite game of winners and losers. Game B is the infinite game of co-creation.”
Not long ago, a friend said to me, “It’s like we are just now getting to the point where we can finally address the problem of governance.”
True!
In some ways, humans have been in an organizational fugue since the beginning of history. Most of our coordination mechanisms have evolved from primitive habits rather than purposeful design specs.
In other words, strict, regimented hierarchies with alpha- or dominator-type personalities have almost always been the norm for organizing and coordinating society. We can call this the hierarch dilemma, a term for the fact that humans can’t seem to dislodge themselves from centralized power and top-down control. This organizational form typifies institutions of all stripes: businesses, government, social clubs, and so on ad nauseam. But hierarchy is a vestigial organ. It is something we have outgrown.
And sure, it works. Kind of. Things get done because assertive personalities project their will. This scheme has sustained itself spectacularly because it has evolved alongside technologies ranging from writing and double-entry bookkeeping to cadastral maps, then to CRMs, databases, surveillance architectures, and other modern tech that make organizing and controlling people at scale much easier. In Against the Grain, James C. Scott traces the origins of top-down rule to grain agriculture and the record-keeping that followed: crops that could be counted, stored, and taxed made populations legible, and these surveilled populations became easier to control from above.
But if hierarchy is a product of particular historical conditions rather than a law of nature, then its persistence is a choice, and we can weigh those choices and potentially reject them for better options. On that note, the costs of continuing to organize this way cannot be overstated. Hierarchical, centralized coordination may ostensibly work in narrow domains, but it also generates downstream consequences and undue harm.
Game A: Rivalrous Dysfunctions
When top-down coordination schemes emerge, they create a zero-sum generator function.
In other words, people begin to play the finite game of capturing and maintaining power. They vie for top ranks and prestigious positions, optimizing for their own outcomes and well-being. Collective flourishing scarcely enters the calculation.
This is not to say that everyone in these systems lacks empathy or can’t see the harm they cause. Many of them can. The problem is that the system punishes anyone who acts to rectify the harms. In a rivalrous environment, individuals must choose to satisfy their ambitions because solving system-engineered problems comes at an exorbitant cost. In this way, a person may want a better world but won’t pursue goals to satisfy that desire when they can be handsomely rewarded for making the world worse off.
But I want to be clear. I am not making the case that humans are inherently broken or that our psychology is hardwired for domination. No gene inevitably dooms us. Certain paradigms simply reward the most aggressive parts of our nature at the expense of the rest. As Frank Herbert wrote in Chapterhouse: Dune:
“All governments suffer a recurring problem: Power attracts pathological personalities. It is not that power corrupts but that it is magnetic to the corruptible.”
Herbert’s point and mine align: hierarchy attracts pathological personalities, and then it trains everyone to behave similarly. Our civil coordination systems are stuck in a bad habit, one that has been reinforced for ages. And like any bad habit, the costs compound over time.
We see these costs everywhere: political power grabs, corruption, arms races, warfare, ocean acidification, the spread of PFAS into the world’s most pristine regions, deforestation in the planet’s most vital tropical biomes, and more. Daniel Schmachtenberger frames this as the “generator function” of existential risk: the underlying dynamics that cause us to generate new catastrophic and existential risks faster than we can address them. Some of these are zero-sum fights over power. Others are worse than zero-sum, where players “win” locally while socializing the costs onto the commons and onto people who haven’t been born yet. Both flow from the same rivalrous logic. Most of our governmental institutions and democratic operating systems run on this wavelength. It likewise drives nearly all of our species’ cultural and social malfunctions.
The late Jim Rutt, who helped found the Game B network in 2012, called this mode of play Game A. He described it as the social structures and dynamics that define our current civilization, characterized by rivalry, power asymmetries, and short-term optimization at the expense of long-term flourishing. A Game A civilization is one in which everyone plays a finite, rivalrous game. In this dog-eat-dog environment, everyone ends up at each other’s throats because life is instantiated as a winner-take-all simulation. That’s why most people feel like life, work, and play are one massive rat race.
But what if we could change from a Game A to a Game B civilization? The building blocks for one are being assembled right now, and that work starts with rethinking and rebuilding our governance primitives.
Game B: Rethinking Governance
First, what is Game B?
Game B refers to a society that has embraced an infinite game. The distinction comes from religious scholar James Carse, who argued that finite games are played to win, while infinite games are played to keep playing. As Carse put it:
“A finite game is played for the purpose of winning, an infinite game for the purpose of continuing the play.”
In a Game B world, we collectively prioritize mutual well-being, holistic betterment, and human happiness. The game, by design, is endless, so people are incentivized to play for and with each other rather than against each other. In this type of civilization, we do not build governance structures that embolden pathological personalities or incentivize planetary annihilation. Instead, we focus on collecting multiparty wins and accounting for externalities. Game B aims to be an omni-win game variant that minimizes power asymmetries and scales globally.
Talk is cheap, though, and the vision at first glance sounds utopian. How do we practically solve the hierarch dilemma and change the civilizational operating agreement? It is a nontrivial problem. But there is an approach, one which Polis Labs is taking.
We must start with the humble proposition that we know nothing about governance.
Assume that everything we know about human decision-making, complex social processing, and governance is wrong. Or, at the very least, we should assume that the structure and functioning of our civilization are off-kilter. In this regard, we can adopt an attitude of open experimentation. This experimentation aims to yield new governance primitives that replace outmoded methods of coordination and organization.
A governance primitive is a foundational algorithm or protocol that provides initial rules for organization. Think of it as a starting point for human interaction and alignment. We can start these primitives with simple questions about our communities or institutions. Basic questions like these:
Who will wash the dishes?
Who will be a member of the community?
How do equity and agreements work?
How do conflict and dispute resolution function?
What does punishment for defection look like?
All of these questions get at the heart of human organizing, and in a community setting, none are definitively settled. Each community and individual probably has a different idea of how it should function.
Setting new primitives lets us work on these problems from the bottom up, starting with the community and its participants. Think of this as retooling polycentric governance through purposeful design specs. We can call this endeavor polycentric design theory (PDT). But what even is “polycentric governance”?
Polycentric governance is the idea that organizational structures and coordination schemes for human communities emerge bottom-up through autonomous actors at the grassroots level. In this sense, the local community shapes governance as a kind of “common law” or shared communal understanding, rather than imposing arbitrary top-down rules. Polycentricity also involves spontaneity, holding that governance emerges from a mix of culture, custom, mutuality, and a shared sense of ethical obligation.
The term has a deep history. Vincent Ostrom, Charles Tiebout, and Robert Warren introduced the term “polycentric” to the study of governance in 1961, in a paper on how overlapping local authorities in metropolitan areas coordinate. Elinor Ostrom spent the following decades studying polycentricity in the field. Her research on irrigation systems and fisheries showed that communities can govern shared resources without either a central authority or privatization, and she distilled what worked into a set of design principles. She won the Nobel Prize in economics for it in 2009. Ostrom found that successful commons governance required clearly defined boundaries, collective-choice arrangements that allow most resource appropriators to participate in decision-making, and effective monitoring by monitors who are part of, or accountable to, the appropriators.
Which brings us to an apparent paradox. If polycentric governance emerges spontaneously, how can anyone design it? Ostrom’s work points toward the answer. You don’t design the outcome. You design the conditions, how rules get made and how disputes get heard, and then let communities fill in the rest. Then see what works. PDT is the practice of deliberately studying those conditions across many communities at once, rather than waiting a few centuries for custom and luck to sort it out.
We now have the capability to do exactly that. A movement for building parallel societies worldwide has emerged. Without getting into the fine details, these are physical communities of like-minded people that intend to set their own cultural norms and governance rules outside the scope of established orders.
The Polycentric Renaissance
Polis Labs has embedded itself within many of these novel parallel societies. We learned first that even the most ambitious communities struggle with basic coordination problems. Imagine having the technology of the gods, yet still grappling with how to organize kitchen duties. It’s a humbling reminder of how much foundational work remains to be done
Without singling out a particular community, people often don’t want to do the dishes and end up neglecting the duty, even if they ate the food that dirtied them. It sounds almost trite or asinine, but at its core, who will do the dishes is a major governance concern. Not because the problem itself is fundamentally serious, but because failing at dish duty could expose deeper gaps in other governance activities, which contaminate the whole community. We’ve seen this happen on the ground too many times.
Nonetheless, these parallel societies have provided us with invaluable insights into the state of human governance. They offer a petri dish for experimenting with governance at a density and speed we haven’t seen before. People have tried this kind of thing, of course. Monasteries, kibbutzim, the Icelandic Commonwealth, and the communities Ostrom studied all ran their own experiments. What’s new is the combination: dozens of communities launching at once, members who can actually leave, digital tools for coordinating across borders, and researchers in a position to compare results. For most of modern history, governments and other large institutions held a near-monopoly on governance, and participants had little ability to exit. Without the possibility of exit, governance experimentation can turn hostile or even violent.
Many people have also assumed, somewhat arrogantly, that governance is a solved problem. Democracy, the story goes, delivers the most freedom, provides a laundry list of services to its citizens, and enforces the rule of law through a constitution. The problem is that democracy still wound up being a top-down operating system, despite early attempts to federate its operations. In most of the modern world, it has also been hijacked and abused by Game A actors. Anyone can simply take a look at the University of Hawaii’s statistics on democide to understand the toll “democracy” and the nation-state have wrought on the world. Professor R.J. Rummel’s research estimates that governments killed approximately 262 million of their own citizens during the 20th century alone, a figure that dwarfs combat deaths from all wars during the same period.
The parallel-society ecosystem we have now offers the opportunity to run governance experiments and unleash a polycentric theory of peaceful governance design. At Polis Labs, we just call the discipline “applied human governance.” It is a form of methodological sensemaking in governance, a long-overdue invention in the realm of human organization. Our previous options have mostly been mainstream political science, which tends to study and defend the institutions we already have, plus some ethnology and anthropology (which are strictly research areas and not necessarily mechanisms for creating praxis). The notable exception is the Bloomington School the Ostroms built, and this work leans heavily on that tradition. From my perspective, what is happening is a real transition in human sensemaking for social organization.
A New Field of Inquiry
In practice, this means new parallel societies, network states, cyberstates, ecovillages, special economic zones, and others are coming online, enabling broader polycentric exploration of coordination. Interestingly, many of these communities emerged because of poor governance in their home territories, where governments have imposed so much red tape that doing business is hard, or where fees and taxes make it infeasible.
This represents a kind of polycentric renaissance, whereby being outside of official order gives these communities the elbow room to finally experiment and learn. We can take a polycentric approach to human governance and share that information among the different communities. We can establish baseline patterns for good governance frameworks and refine these models through iterative experimentation.
Polis Labs is conducting field research to further establish polycentric governance design as a field. The objective is to gather enough data to support rolling out new models. We also decided that starting humbly with conflict resolution, rather than some crazy equity experiment with a token and some land, was the smart move. If a community can’t figure out how to do the damn dishes, they probably won’t know how to allocate massive amounts of capital through their newly minted crypto token.
Indeed, if we can’t figure out who will do the dishes, we probably won’t be able to solve the primary governance crises we’re facing. Only time will tell.
References
Carse, James P. Finite and Infinite Games: A Vision of Life as Play and Possibility. New York: Free Press, 1986.
Herbert, Frank. Chapterhouse: Dune. New York: G.P. Putnam’s Sons, 1985.
Ostrom, Elinor. Governing the Commons: The Evolution of Institutions for Collective Action. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1990.
Ostrom, Vincent, Charles M. Tiebout, and Robert Warren. “The Organization of Government in Metropolitan Areas: A Theoretical Inquiry.” American Political Science Review 55, no. 4 (1961): 831-842.
Rummel, Rudolph J. Death by Government. New Brunswick: Transaction Publishers, 1994. See also: https://www.hawaii.edu/powerkills/
Rutt, Jim. “What is Game B?” The Jim Rutt Show, 2020. https://jimruttshow.com/what-is-game-b/
Schmachtenberger, Daniel. “The Generator Functions of Existential Risk.” The Consilience Project, 2021. https://consilienceproject.org/the-generator-functions-of-existential-risk/
Scott, James C. Against the Grain: A Deep History of the Earliest States. New Haven: Yale University Press, 2017.






I love reading your work!!!
I love the down to earth practical issue of doing dishes.
My voice is often dismissed for so many reasons. I believe it is appropriate here if we are talking about bottom up experimentation.
Before community level work we have family level work. What do our personal relationships look like? With partners and children?
I think of the quote:
“A man cannot govern a nation if he cannot govern a city; he cannot govern a city if he cannot govern a family; he cannot govern a family unless he can govern himself; and he cannot govern himself unless his passions are subject to reason.” Hugo Grotius
It’s not 100% but governing from within inevitably moves outward to our external world.
So back to dishes… I raised, parented, home educated, and governed my 7 children. I moved from dictator who dictated who did dishes. That didn’t work for building relationships. It led to resentment and distance!
So what’s the goal and who decides? I wanted reciprocal relationships.
I experimented with many ways and landed on negotiation. Some children hated dishes or never could get them clean enough. I didn’t want to fight or stress, so I honored their being and figured out what worked for both or all of us. Some never did dishes! They did other things. Some did them a lot.
Also I had to be willing to renegotiate because things change over time.
Families are different and similar to communities so worth considering. Personal healthy relationships are foundational.
I realize it's meant mostly as a metaphor, but the dishes problem can be easily solved by requiring everyone to bring their own clean dish, and to take it with them when they leave. Perhaps other intractable problems can be solved with a similar approach.